Box Score Breakdown: Arkansas 34, South Carolina 6

Box Score Breakdown: Arkansas 34, South Carolina 6

Adam Ford

Ryan Silverfield is going to remember the score “34-6” when he looks back at his first season in Fayetteville. Twice with his back against the wall, his Hogs won a game by that score to help reverse some of the negative narrative around the program.

The Hogs put together their best game of the season in a 34-6 romp of a very banged-up South Carolina team. The main story was the Arkansas defense, which pressured Carolina quarterback Cutter Woods 11 times and forced four turnovers, including a pick-six by Joker Johnson, his second of the year.

Arkansas’ offense was still iffy, failing to gain 400 yards against a below-average SEC defense, but the big number was that they turned it over zero times. They have not turned it over in either SEC win this year, which is not a coincidence.

We’ve discussed this ever since Silverfield was hired, but the modus operandi of Silverfield football is to punish opponents that can’t get out of their own way. Every year in the SEC, there are multiple teams that are devastated by injuries, coaching drama, or hilarious low-IQ football. For the last decade-and-a-half, one of those SEC teams is usually Arkansas. Silverfield’s plan is to turn the hunted into the hunter and build a resume by beating mistake-prone teams.

South Carolina is definitely one of those teams vulnerable to what Arkansas wants to do. Shane Beamer is a pretty good coach (probably?), but he’s very Houston Nutt-like in that his teams are a threat to pull a massive upset in any given week, but they are horribly inconsistent and often lose games they really should win. In that sense, having a star defender like Dylan Stewart and an offensive coordinator like Kendal Briles is really perfect for Beamer. Stewart will make all sorts of havoc plays, but he’ll also get you a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty every now and again, like the one that kept a Razorback drive alive in the third quarter (full disclosure: I didn’t love that call, although Stewart should have stopped sooner).

And Briles will be Briles: great scheme, plenty of yards, good quarterback development, but also he’ll do this in the redzone:

So Arkansas’ two SEC wins have come against a bad team (Vanderbilt) and an injured-and-inconsistent team (South Carolina). They also beat two non-power teams (Tulsa, North Alabama) and came very close to beating a team with a new QB (Tennessee) and a not-great team (Auburn). Teams with good quarterback play and no internal drama (Utah, Georgia, Missouri) have crushed them. Texas A&M is really the sole outlier, as in theory the Hogs should have at least been close.

If you think that’s a criticism or you are disappointed by the way Silverfield is going to try to succeed, consider that you’ve watched Arkansas football go 2-10 three times in the last eight years prior to his arrival. The Hogs have won one or zero SEC games five times since 2012 and had a winning SEC record once. Beating bad, dysfunctional, or inconsistent teams with some degree of consistency would be an upgrade for this program.

Silverfield’s long-term success will depend on whether he can raise the bar of what is considered a “bad” team relative to Arkansas. Right now, it’s just Vanderbilt. But that’s been the case for years. The goal needs to be to slowly add other schools that are “bad” to the list: Mississippi State, then maybe a South Carolina, an Auburn, a Kentucky, maybe eventually a Missouri or Ole Miss. There are no quick-fixes to get there. It requires being better at talent evaluation, better at retention, and better at development, and being better at those things over multiple seasons. That’s what Hunter Yurachek signed us all up for when he hired Silverfield. It may turn out to be a good hire or a bad hire, we don’t really know that for sure yet. At the least, we can safely say that it’s time to stop any comparisons to Chad Morris.

So yes, fans stormed the field after the win. It’s a little bit silly to me, but I guess I’m old-school in thinking that field storms should be reserved for program-defining wins.

That said, Silverfield (and the current roster) have taken a ton of heat, only some of it deserved, so a field storm is a way to show appreciation both to him and the team for continuing to improve and get better. Was that worth the $500,000 fine? Probably not, but I guess I get it.

Advanced stats

The “noise-weighted score” massively devalues the impact of “noisy” plays: plays that significantly impact the actual score but are not exactly reliable or replicable things. Stuff like the Gamecocks suffering two redzone turnovers and tossing a pick-six, or the Hogs getting a touchdown pass on a third-and-10. But as Al Davis said, “Just win baby”, and it goes back to how Silverfield wants to win that the Hogs benefitted from the noise. They’ve been losing to the noise for years.

Five Carolina drives earned a first down inside the Arkansas 40. Here’s how they ended:

  • Missed field goal
  • Kendal Briles special (fumble)
  • Kendal Briles special (quarterback throws the ball out of the endzone in field goal range as time expires)
  • Touchdown
  • Interception

Goodness, that’s bad. Still, even without those “noisy” plays, Arkansas gained a higher chunk of available yards and had two fewer turnovers.

Cutter Woods wasn’t that bad in his first career start. He was generally accurate. But Ron Roberts decided to light him up and throw all kinds of crazy looks at him. The Gamecocks got a few explosive passes out of the deal, but they also got a lot of mistakes.

The blitzing led to 11 pressures. The Hogs only got home once – this team is very bad at finishing sacks – but the biggest successes came when the Hogs dropped out of the blitzes and utilitized the “simulated pressures” that made Roberts famous in coaching circles.

Take the pick-six, where the Hogs drop out of a blitz, which confuses the receiver, who stops on his route:

Watch that a couple times and you can see how difficult that is to play as an offense. The secondary was backed off and the front was showing blitz, so Woods knows he needs to throw quickly underneath. But the Hogs expected that, so Joker is jumping that route. The receiver is surprised to see a curl-flat defender right where he needs to go, so he hesitates and gives up a pick-six.

I was a fan of the Roberts hire from the beginning, and this game is proof of concept of how Roberts fits right into what Silverfield wants to do here. You want to win by being the team that makes fewer mistakes? Run a defense that forces mistakes. Travis Williams tried that by becoming Mr. Blitz, but that’s not really advisable in this day and age of college football. Williams got eaten up way too often. If you want to force the issue against opposing offenses, you have to do stuff like this where you maintain the threat of a blitz while being able to drop seven defenders into coverage.

It’s notable that almost every defender on the two-deep is eligible to return next year, so retention is going to be a major offseason priority. Johnson, Lewis, Khmori House, and Ja’Quavion Smith could all return, as could some young defensive tackles like Danny Beale III and Antonio Sandel-Bascomb, who have both seen a major increase in snaps in recent weeks. If Arkansas can avoid poachers, this defense could be nasty next season with only a few offseason additions (one edge, one linebacker, one safety).

As for the offense…

The tougher decision will come on offense. The zero turnovers was very good, but Arkansas once again failed to reach 400 yards of offense, this time against a below-average defense.

Here’s what we’ve seen this year:

You’ve basically had one good offensive game all season, and it came against the worst team in the SEC. You’ve had three “yikes” games: Utah, Texas A&M, and Missouri.

The case against Cramsey. You simply have to be better on offense. The Hogs have improved as a run team, but they are still not very good there. They’re probably going to end up failing to score 40 points and topping 30 just three times in 12 games. The total lack of explosives is a problem, because that’s part of the offensive design. This just isn’t a big-play offense. It’s an offense designed to stay on schedule and avoid turnovers. That will work against bad teams (Vanderbilt), but in any other game, you’re just trying to be good enough for your defense to bail you out. Given the history, it’s tough to see that working long-term at Arkansas. Related to that, you can see a clear lack of killer instinct from Cramsey as a playcaller. He does fine while nursing a lead, but many of his play calls when playing from behind are baffling. If you want to have major success, you have to win close games, and Cramsey hasn’t shown much as a playcaller when the stakes are high.

The case for Cramsey. KJ Jackson, who hasn’t been great but also hasn’t been terrible, has another year. As we saw in our deep dive earlier this year, returning your starting quarterback is the single-biggest factor in year-over-year improvement over the last 30 years of Razorback football. Jackson could potentially return all five offensive linemen and have a clear top receiving target (Antonio Jordan). The Hogs would need to go portaling for a couple speedy slot receivers, and they may want to invest in a better running back, but the pieces are there for major improvement. As for playcalling, this is Cramsey’s first year calling plays in a power conference. He’s spent his entire playing and coaching career at the FCS and G4 levels. You can question whether that makes him a good hire initially, but it is also true that you can teach old dogs new tricks, and experience can help be a better situational playcaller.

If you get the opportunity to dump Cramsey for, say, Mike Norvell, you have to consider it. But on the flip side, as I wrote about Chad Morris and staff running off Ty Storey after the 2018 season:

My longstanding suspicion is that Morris panicked after a 2-10 season and overhauled his roster – especially his quarterback room – when he didn’t really need to, resulting in the 2019 collapse. In hindsight, doubling down on Ty Storey at quarterback and focusing on improving the defense and offensive line might have been the move, as the Morris staff pulled in an amazing recruiting class that offseason. Instead, the new-look 2019 offense opened the season with two horrific performances (Portland State and Ole Miss) that essentially killed the Morris era.

The application? Don’t panic during the rebuild. After Bielema’s first team went 3-9, he didn’t replace Brandon Allen as his quarterback, and Allen eventually became an elite quarterback. Petrino and Pittman both started senior quarterbacks during their first season, but the second-year starter was on the bench in Year 1. Neither brought in a serious competitor to Ryan Mallett or KJ Jefferson, and both offenses took off in Year 2.

Firing Cramsey after one season would qualify as panicking during the rebuild. Those numbers in the chart above are not great, but they are better than they were in September, and patience might end up being the best option here.

Highlights

Up next

It’s hard to see the Hogs winning either of their final two games, although you never really know where LSU’s head will be at after they took their fourth loss on Saturday.

This Saturday will be very tough. Texas’s offense has issues, but the Longhorns are elite everywhere else and will likely be too much for the Hogs, especially in Austin.

3 thoughts on “Box Score Breakdown: Arkansas 34, South Carolina 6”

  1. Man I just want to say that I anticipate these breakdowns every week because they are phenomenal! Thank you for putting this together, it truly is the best razorback content available on the internet in my opinion! I hate Cramsey, but I think your research is valuable. If you can get an unbelievable hire to come in here at OC then do it, but I don’t know how feasible that is or if anybody would even want to come here at this moment.

Leave a Reply